University Can Limit Solicitations to Walkway

A Vincennes University policy restricting uninvited “solicitations” to a walkway outside the student union and banning such solicitations from the school’s library lawn does not violate the uninvited speaker’s constitutional rights. The policy was initiated after an incident by Brother Jim in 2001 who, uninvited, began preaching on the library lawn of the public university […]
Continue Reading

Honking Horn Costs Teacher Her Job

An elementary school teacher can be fired for telling her class that she honked her car’s horn in support of demonstrators against the war in Iraq, the Seventh Circuit found. The appellate court said the teacher had been told that she could teach the controversy about the war in Iraq “drawing out arguments from all […]
Continue Reading

Prohibiting Nude Dancing In Bars Does Not Violate First Amendment

Prohibiting nude and seminude dancing in establishments that serve alcoholic beverages does not violate the dancer’s First Amendment rights of expression, the Illinois Supreme Court said. The court upheld the validity of a City of Chicago ordinance that bans nude and semi-nude dancing in licensed establishments selling liquor by the drink. If dancers want to […]
Continue Reading

Anti-Bush T-Shirt OK to Wear to School

A Vermont middle school was wrong to force a student to cover up part of an anti-drug and anti-Bush message on a T-shirt he wore to school because such action interfered with his First Amendment rights to engage in political speech. The front of the T-shirt had the words “George W. Bush, Chicken-Hawk-In-Chief” with a […]
Continue Reading

Law Banning Sexually Oriented Billboards Unconstitutional

A Missouri statute that regulated advertising for businesses that offer sexually explicit entertainment and material–prohibiting such advertising within one mile of a highway– unconstitutionally restricts commercial speech, a federal appeals court ruled. The court found that the statute as written, as well as interpreted by the trial court, violated the First Amendment. The statute prohibited […]
Continue Reading

Violent Video Games Statute Unconstitutional

A Minnesota statute that would fine those under 17 who rent or purchase certain video games has been declared unconstitutional by a U.S. District Court. The Minnesota Restricted Video Games Act was enacted on May 31, 2006. It stated in part that: “[A] person under the age of 17 may not knowingly rent or purchase […]
Continue Reading

But Would Jesus Wear the T-Shirt?

A high school can ban a t-shirt that displays a purportedly religious message against homosexuality in response to a day intended to “teach tolerance of others, particularly those of a different sexual orientation.” The t-shirt read “BE ASHAMED, OUR SCHOOL EMBRACED WHAT GOD HAS CONDEMNED” on the front and “HOMOSEXUALITY IS SHAMEFUL” on the back. […]
Continue Reading

Taxpayer May Pursue Notre Dame For Restitution

It may not be another bowl loss, but Notre Dame lost its bid to stop a taxpayer from pursuing the university for funds it received for training teachers for Catholic schools in violation of the establishment clause of the U.S. Constitution. The Seventh Circuit found that a taxpayer can continue its lawsuit to have Notre […]
Continue Reading

Discrimination Suit Won’t Play for Church Music Director

A fired church music director cannot use the federal courts to sue for age discrimination, the Seventh Circuit affirmed. The court ruled that the selection of music at church is religious in nature. As a result, the First Amendment bars the music director’s suit against the church for age discrimination. The case was filed after […]
Continue Reading